In a mammoth decision, Beach J has held that Branhaven’s patent application, No 2010202253, entitled “Compositions, methods and systems for inferring bovine traits” “is deficient in terms of:
(a) lack of clarity;
(b) a failure to define the invention; and
(c) related to some questions of construction, lack of utility.”
His Honour, however, rejected attacks on the basis of manner of manufacture, novelty, inventive step and fair basis. Branhaven will be given time (usually 60 days) to consider whether it can amend to overcome the objections.
At 949 paragraphs there is more than a little light reading!
The ABC has an excitable summary here.
Meat & Livestock Australia Limited v Cargill, Inc  FCA 51